Bush and GOP Leaders Call for More Budget Cuts

In a news conference yesterday, President Bush put pressure on Congress to pay for as much of the hurricane relief as possible by cutting spending. He urged that funding be cut in both non-defense discretionary spending and entitlement spending. His comments prompted House Budget Committee Chairman Jim Nussle (R-IA) to claim that he will seek even more cuts in entitlement expenditures than those laid out in April's budget resolution. Currently the resolution instructs that entitlement spending be cut by $35 million over the next five years. Nussle said in an interview that Gulf Coast reconstruction costs should be partly offset through across-the-board reductions in discretionary spending, beginning with a 2 percent "haircut" from the $843 billion agreed to under the FY06 budget." The Coalition on Human Needs has an analysis highlighting how those cuts will affect human needs programs. One has to wonder where these gestures of fiscal responsibility were when Congress passed trillions of dollars worth of tax cuts in 2001 and 2003, which were not offset by any spending cuts. That Congress also wants to push ahead with extending reduced rates for capital gains and dividends taxes -- tax breaks which benefit primarily the wealthy -- further serves to illustrate that these spending cuts could be avoided. Bush also asserted yesterday that even though Congress has a "diminished appetite" for overhauling Social Security, he has not taken the issue off the table. Bush said, "Social Security for me is never off. It's a long-term problem that's going to need to be addressed." However, the solutions he claimed to support a few months ago would lower guarenteed benefits and cost $700 billion over the next decade. Not exactly a great way to cut down federal spending.

read in full

Disaster Reconstruction: How Effective Are Tax Breaks?

On September 28 the Senate Finance Committee held a hearing looking at various tax incentives and how they will assist in Gulf Coast reconstruction operations. Governors Blanco of Louisiana, Barbour of Mississippi, and Riley of Alabama testified, and while they did not agree on preferred tax incentives, they all requested some form of tax benefits ranging from zeroing out capital gains taxes on investments to accelerated depreciation to various bond programs. Other witnesses, however, questioned the use of tax cuts as an effective method of providing post-disaster relief.
  • Daniel Doctoroff, the Deputy Mayor for Economic Development and Rebuilding for New York City who helped direct post-9/11 operations, told the Committee that in his experience tax provisions were a cumbersome method for delivering disaster assistance. He argued that benefits are provided only if businesses and economic growth respond to predicted forecasts, and mentioned that Congressional appropriations were a much better way of addressing relief and rebuilding needs.
  • George Yin, Chief of Staff for the Joint Committee on Taxation, also voiced skepticism regarding the effectiveness of tax incentives. He testified that tax breaks are particularly ineffective when addressing the needs of low-income earners, particularly because would-be beneficiaries are not aware of many of the tax provisions or how to obtain them. Also, low-income earners stand to receive less in tax benefits overall because they have less-taxable income.

read in full

Like the Federal Deficit, CEO Pay is on the Rise

Along with deficits rising, it appears the ratio of CEO pay to worker pay is also rising. As this United for a Fair Economy report highlights, CEO pay has shot up over the past few years, and now, while the average CEO makes $11.8 million per year, the average worker makes $27,460 per year. The ratio has spiked from 301-1 to 431-1. Perhaps even more unsettling news is that 46 large companies who made more than $30 billion in profits in 2003 paid absolutely no income taxes that year. Also, the report notes that the CEO's presiding over the most underfunded pensions had salaries that were, on average, 72 percent more than other CEO salaries. Congressional GOP leaders and the administration often mention the "strong economy" we are currently experiencing. It is important to remember that while the economy may look strong for some, it is not strong for many of the workers who are earning a disgracefully low minimum wage.

read in full

GAO Comptroller: Evaluation of Tax Expenditures Necessary

Last Friday, General Accountability Office Comptroller David Walker strongly urged a "strategic, long range, and integrated" examination of tax expenditures to test their relevance and priority during a time when the federal budget is experiencing increasing strains. His comments came during the unveiling of a new GAO report recommending that the OMB and the Treasury take steps to ensure greater transparency of, and accountability for, tax expenditures. Walker emphasized to reporters, as he has in the past, the importance of putting the nation on a more "prudent and sustainable course for the long term." He insisted that doling out tax preferences has an impact on the government's bottom line, and at a time when we are experiencing high deficits, it is important to reevaluate some of those expenditures.

read in full

More On Cost of Rebuilding; Congress Passes Tax Bill

Many Republican leaders in the House and Senate are worried about the costs of rebuilding after Katrina, even though President Bush has promised, and rightly so, to devote all the funds needed to help the devastated region. Republicans who are worried about excessive deficit-financed spending are pushing for the costs will be offset (most are suggesting by cutting the budget elsewhere). To appease them, OMB Director Josh Bolten said Tuesday that the administration would consider offsets, but did not offer any details about what would be cut and by how much. As Stan Collender correctly points out (subscription required), any offsets proposed by the administration would to little, if anything, to reduce the amount Katrina relief spending will add to the deficit, and the national debt. Because President Bush refuses to even consider not extending or rolling back some of his first term tax cuts, it will be future generations who will be paying for reconstructing the Gulf Coast. The federal government is required by law to pay at least 75 percent of the cost of rebuilding public infrastructure after a disaster (1988 Stafford Act). To comply, Congress -- besides approving about $64 billion in emergency spending -- has agreed on a tax-relief bill to expand deductions this year for victims. The final bill was scored by the Joint Committee on Taxation as costing $6.1 billion over 10 years. Congress hopes these targeted tax cuts will spur employment of low-income workers on the Gulf Coast. In addition, President Bush signed three bills today to help in the aftermath of the disaster. The bills waive Pell Grant and other federal student loan requirements for displaced college students and expand Temporary Assistance to Needy Families eligibility for victims. CNN.com: House Passes Tax Breaks for Hurricane Katrina Victims

read in full

Bush Decision to Waive Wage Protections Could Be Illegal

As many surely know by now, the White House decision to suspend its obligations under the Davis-Bacon Act to require a fair minimum wage for contractors working on the reconstruction and recovery efforts in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina will have a direct and drastically negative impact on many of the very victims of the hurricane. Some have noted the irony of this decision given that the hurricane's devastation was compounded by years of poverty and low-wages throughout the Gulf region.

read in full

Committees Get to Work; Soc. Security Tabled For Now

Congressional tax committees have set to work and are looking into how tax policy can be used to help victims of the recent disaster, both immediately and in the long run. Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee Charles Grassley (R-IA) told reporters in a morning news conference that his committee would be looking into relief efforts associated with past natural disasters in order to determine which policies have been effective. Then, they will look into applying similar policies to help those affected by Katrina. Meanwhile, in the House the Chairman of the Ways and Means Committee, Bill Thomas (R-CA), is apparently exploring a three-phase approach addressing the initial humanitarian concerns, followed by infrastructure concerns, and finally long-term reconstruction. The first measure, which could move as early as September 8, deals with getting money to individuals through TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families). The measure would remove a lot of red tape and provide immediate assistance for a number of families. Also, it is pretty clear that any sort of work on Social Security legislation is off the table now that Congressional leaders have their hands full dealing with the disaster. Sen. Olympia Snowe (R-ME) told BNA News Services that "Major issues are overtaking a number of issues like Social Security. It's hard to foresee a legislative agenda addressing the long-term issues associated with Social Security this fall." Grassley made similar comments, telling reporters that his top priority this fall will be disaster-related measures, the Roberts nomination, budget reconciliation legislation and appropriation bills, and then Social Security.

read in full

$51.8 Billion Package Requested By President

The Associated Press is reporting President Bush will request $51.8 billion in additional emergency relief funding for Hurricane Katrina from Congress. As the cost of the Federal Emergency Management Agency's daily operations in the Gulf Coast climbed to over $700 million, it became clear the previous emergency supplemental approved last week for $10.5 billion would not last long. The request could be approved by Congress as early as tomorrow. The second supplemental request will include $1.4 billion for the military and $400 million for the Army Corps of Engineers, which is working to repair breaks in the levee system around New Orleans. The remaining $50 billion will go to FEMA. This is unlikely to be the last emergency funding for this disaster, as Congressional leaders and recovery experts are expecting the total damages to cost upwards of $150 billion. In addition, yesterday, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released a report examining the economic repercussions of Hurricane Katrina to Congressional leaders. The CBO found the economic effects of the disaster could be as severe as a one-percentage point drop in econonmic growth and the possible loss of up to 400,000 jobs by the end of 2005.

read in full

Congressional Action on Pensions More Likely Than SS

Congress is more likely to act on pension reform than social security reform this year, according to today's BNA: "Congress ultimately may fail to find accord on Social Security reforms and instead pass more targeted pension reform legislation when it returns from its summer recess, sources who follow the issue told BNA Aug. 31." Michael Tanner, director of the Cato Institute's Project on Social Security Choice, told BNA Aug. 31 that Congress is likely to pass a pension bill, even if it fails to muster support for Social Security changes. "You could get a decent pension bill regardless of what happens with Social Security," Tanner said. Jason Furman, a senior fellow with the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, rarely agrees with Tanner, a proponent of Social Security payroll tax-financed individual investment accounts. But Furman also said he expected Congress to act on pensions. "Something on the defined benefit [pension plan] side has to happen," Furman told BNA Aug. 31. Furman said he anticipated that Congress would feel compelled to pass provisions aimed at strengthening the funding of defined benefit pension plans and measures aimed at bolstering the federal pension insurer, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. "On Social Security, it is extremely unlikely that anything will be enacted by Congress. What the Republicans are trying to do is retreat from this issue," Furman said.

read in full

Census Data Shows American Continue to Struggle

The Census Bureau released its annual report on poverty, income, and health insurance in the United States and the news is not good. The number of Americans living in poverty rose for the forth year in a row as 1.1 million more Americans were officially poor in 2004 than the year before. The data shows almost 1 in 5 American children live in poverty. In additon, almost 1 million more Americans lacked health insurance, primarily due to a decrease in employer-provided health care. Unfortunately for working families, total household income remained stagnant and income for men and women employed in full-time jobs decreased significantly. This is the first time ever that household income has failed to increase for five straight years. The Census data give just a glimpse of the reality being faced by more and more working Americans who are being forced to live without health insurance and have less money with which to purchase their own as employers increasingly focus on their profit margins at the expense of their workers. The current economic policies are not working for most Americans - only those already well-off. The decline in indicators of poverty and income for the fourth straight year should be a wake-up call for members of Congress and the administration who are seeking to make those policies permanent. It is time for a change. Read More: > Census Data Full Report> Income Stagnated and Poverty Rose in 2004, Census Shows > Coalition on Human Needs Release on Census Poverty Data > Economic Recovery Failed to Benefit Much of Population in 2004

read in full

Pages

Subscribe to The Fine Print: blog posts from Center for Effective Government