NYT Gets Estate Tax Issue Just About Perfect

The New York Times published an excellent article on the estate tax in Sunday's business section. The article accurately dispells many of the false claims made by opponents of the tax and does a very good job of showcasing who exactly would benefit from repeal of the tax. It is definitely worth a read...

read in full

CBO Releases More Realistic Budget Projections

About a month after the White House released its highly misleading and overly optimistic budget projections, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released their projections today. The CBO report projects a $331 billion deficit for FY05, a $33 billion reduction since they released an initial estimate earlier this year in March. CBO also has increased their estimate of the total deficits over the next ten years by more than $1.1 trillion to $2.1 trillion. These estimates are much more worrisome than OMB projections released last month as CBO and OMB differ over the ten-year deficits from 2006 - 2015 by more than $600 billion. Unlike the OMB numbers, CBO finds very little reason to be optimistic about the future health of the federal government. They write, "Although the deficit for 2005 is lower than previously expected, the fiscal outlook for the coming decade remains about the same as what CBO described in March." In March, CBO described a very dark future if current policies are continued. This CBO report casts further doubt on administration claims that their economic policies are working to spur strong economic growth and will continue to shrink deficits. CBO has confirmed what many private analysts have reported - that the recent jump in federal revenues are due to short-term and temporary factors that are unsustainable and that over the long-term, the country still faces many large and difficult fiscal challenges. CBO concludes, "Over the long-term, then, growing resource demands...will exert pressure on the budget that economic growth alone will not eliminate." Most strikingly, the CBO report states that if the tax cuts from the administration's first term are extended (with the exception of policies related to the alternative minimum tax), as President Bush has been strongly advocating, deficits over the next decade would increase $1.6 trillion on top of their current projections. The Senate Budget Committee's most senior Democrat Kent Conrad (D-ND) believes the nation needs a "serious fiscal wake-up call" if we are to correct the long-term budget shortfalls that "threaten our economic security." It's time for President Bush to be straight-forward with the American people and begin an honest conversation about adopting alternative policies that will return the country to a sound and sustainable fiscal foundation.

read in full

Sec. Snow Conceeds Economy Not Benefiting All

Earlier this week, Secretary of the Treasury John Snow conceded the slowly-progressing economic recovery has not benefited all Americans equally. Snow said, "The idea...is to explore the things that produce broad-based prosperity and one of the things we know is that less educated people have seen their incomes and wages grow more slowly." Snow's comments come amid slightly more positive economic indicators and increasing business optimism about the economy, but also in conjunction with the release of two reports showing the recovery has been anything but good for most Americans. This week the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities released a report comparing this economic recovery with previous recovery periods and finds that not only is this one less robust but that it is much more unevenly distributed, with corporate profits reaping nearly all the benefits at the exclusion of the labor market. In addition, the Congressional Budget Office released a background paper examining employment during and after the economic recession of 2001. Among its interesting findings, the CBO writes, "both the magnitude and persistence of the decline in the labor force [participation rate] during the past several years are unprecedented."

read in full

Permanency Needed, But Bush Prefers Trashing ET

President Bush has once again weighed in on the estate tax issue, claiming the tax needs to be repealed to establish "certainty in the tax code." All sides in this debate agree with President Bush's concern for the need for certainty, but that can easily be achieved by adjusting the tax structure and moving beyond the phase-out system put in place by Congress in 2001 without repealing the tax. As with Social Security, there are only a few minor adjustments needed to achieve a prudent compromise policy on the estate tax, but for some reason President Bush is more interested in scrapping the tax entirely. It seems clear who's best interests President Bush has at heart.

read in full

Double Standards and Misinformation on the ET

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist took yet another step yesterday in the conservative misinformation campaign against the estate tax in a Wall Street Journal op-ed (subscription required). Frist writes the estate tax "is the cruelest, most unfair tax our government imposes," and that it is "an immoral tax." Neither of these claims could be further from the truth. Contrary to Frist's claim, a recent report by the Congressional Budget Office found that almost no farms and small businesses are unreasonably burdened. According to the study, of all the farms in all the states all across the country, only 27 out of 300 who had to pay estate taxes would have been taxed in excess of their ability to pay with liquid assets. This was when the exemption was $1.5 million. With exemptions already set to rise to $3.5 million by 2009, those remaining farms and businesses will be exempted completely. But if the estate tax battle is not about family farmers and small businesses, who is it about? As the Washington Post reports today - the true battle for repeal is between the few very rich and the even fewer super-rich. Senator Frist's incredulity notwithstanding, what is truly immoral is for conservatives and the Republican Party to continue to push estate tax repeal through a misinformation campaign when there are real problems to address that will require government revenues they are giving away to a very few super-wealthy families. Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid all face fiscal problems in the long-run - and these are problems that will impact millions upon millions of Americans. Therefore, how can Senator Frist (and President Bush) justify spending so much time and effort to repeal a tax benefiting so few Americans while at the same time throwing up their hands and claiming the only solution to the fiscal challenges of the future is to cut supports and benefits for regular Americans? If you don't know the answer to that question, ask your Senators if they do. Send a letter to your Senators expressing your concerns about the current fixation with repealing the estate tax.

read in full

July Jobs Numbers Show Slight Improvement

July's employment numbers released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) showed that the nation's employers have picked up their hiring pace, as payrolls expanded by 207,000 jobs. This was significantly better than both May and June's numbers and bumped the average monthly growth rate for jobs to 191,000 in 2005. There remain many problems with the economy and job market as we continue to slowly move through this economic recovery. First, almost all of the new jobs created in July were in the service industries (generally lower paying jobs with worse benefits) as the employment picture is still very bleak in the manufacturing and good producing sectors (generally higher paying jobs with better benefits). The lack of a rebound in the manufacturing sector continues to be a large problem, particularly for Americans who have been unable to find sufficient employment to replace wages lost when they were laid off their manufacturing job. Second, and perhaps more importantly, job creation is still lagging significantly behind population growth. If job creation and population growth continue along at their current pace, the employment outlook will continue to worsen with each passing month. Read More...
  • July Employment Summary from the BLS
  • Statement from the Center for American Progress
  • July Jobs Picture Analysis by the Economic Policy Institute

read in full

Latest OMB Watcher: August 8, 2005

Below are the latest budget and tax articles from the OMB Watcher:
  • Estate Tax Vote Slated for September -- Take Action Now
  • Office of Management and Budget Continues to Manipulate Budget Projections
To receive the OMB Watcher by email, sign up here

read in full

New Talking Points On Upcoming Estate Tax Vote

One of the first items the Senate is expected to take up when it returns in September is a House-passed bill to permanently repeal the estate tax, and it is quite likely that this repeal bill will ultimately serve as a vehicle for an estate tax reform proposal by Senator Kyl. In order to consider the House-passed bill, the Senate first needs to adopt a motion to proceed to the bill. Under Senate parliamentary rules, it requires 60 votes to “invoke cloture” and vote on this motion. Defeating cloture is the key step to block efforts to repeal the estate tax or prevent enactment of an irresponsible estate tax reform. Now is the time to make calls to your Senators and urge them to:
    1. Vote NO on cloture on the motion to proceed to the estate tax bill; and 2. Oppose any reform effort, such as the Kyl proposal to link the estate tax rate to the capital gains rate, that does not preserve a major portion of the estate tax revenue.
For more information: Read these Talking Points

read in full

Bush Administration Announces Re-Issue of 30-Year Bond

The Bush administration announced last week that the Treasury Department would begin issuing 30-year Treasury bonds again. The bonds were discontinued about four years ago because they were seen as unnecessary due to huge projected surpluses in the federal government. The announcement signals an realization and acceptance that budget deficits are here for the long haul and with looming long-term costs rising, the government needs additional ways to borrow money. Washington Post coverage

read in full

OMB Releases Overly Optimistic Mid-Year Budget Review

The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) released its mid-year budget review on July 13 and trumpeted the lower than expected deficit projections for 2005. The self-congratulatory rhetoric coming out of the White House since has overshadowed true problems down the road. While OMB has lowered its deficit projections for 2005 from $412 billion to $333 billion and continued to claim President Bush is well on his way to cutting the deficit in half by 2009, they continue to omit crucial aspects from their budget analysis and downplay more pressing budgetary concerns beyond 2009. First, the recently released projections to not include a fix to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) after 2005. Many analysts are crediting the expanding reach of the AMT as one of the reasons individual and corporate tax receipts increased so unexpectedly over the last six months. It is widely accepted that Congress will take action soon to restrict the number of Americans who pay the AMT. This will have a profound impact on tax receipts, causing them to fall and in turn increase deficits. For OMB to omit this aspect is misleading and irresponsible. Secondly, as they have done repeatedly, OMB ignores the impact of current policies after the five-year window ending in 2009. According to the White House's own budget calculations released in the president's FY06 budget, if current policies are extended, deficits will begin to climb again after 2009. If these policies continue until the retirement of the baby-boomer generation about a decade later, deficits will skyrocket, reaching double digits as a percentage of GDP. Finally, the mid-year review does not reflect changes to tax policy scheduled to be debated and enacted this fall. Congress agreed to a budget resolution earlier this year calling for $106 billion in additional unpaid-for tax cuts to be passed by year's end. This alone will wipe out the $94 billlion improvement in the deficit OMB is forecasting. Until the White House, and to a certain extent Congress, begin to be more honest and forthright about budget projections and the future effects of changes in tax policy (beyond artificial five- or ten-year windows), budget policy in the U.S. will continue down a dangerous path.

read in full

Pages

Subscribe to The Fine Print: blog posts from Center for Effective Government