FISA Negotiations Continue

Reportedly, an effort to find a compromise on legislation that revises the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) is somewhat moving forward. According to CQ ($$), "Lawmakers and aides doubt that Congress can complete any overhaul of the foreign intelligence surveillance law before the Memorial Day break, yet many say increasingly 'productive' and 'serious' negotiations are under way." Apparently a compromise is being considered in which a secret court would have the authority to decide whether to grant immunity in cases involving telecommunications companies. The companies would have to go before the secret FISA court in order to be eligible for retroactive immunity. This is similar to an amendment Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) offered during the Senate debate, but it was defeated. This proposal is not without objections. The FISA court could be limited in what kind of review it conducts, and possibly far too limited. If the courts can only review orders from the Bush administration, plaintiffs could be denied a fair hearing. Caroline Fredrickson, the director of the American Civil Liberties Union's Washington legislative office was quoted in the CQ article; "We're really very concerned, because putting something that should be handled in the federal court system into a secret court where only one side really has a chance to make its arguments and the general public gets shut out is not really going to advance accountability for the illegal spying this administration has engaged in."
back to Blog