
Debt "Relief" Passes House
by Guest Blogger, 7/9/2002
Yesterday evening, the House passed the Debt Relief Lock-Box
Reconciliation Act for FY 2001 (HR 5173) almost unanimously,
with well more than the required two-thirds majority (381 to
3).
As reported earlier, the bill sets aside $42 billion of the
FY 2001
non-Social Security surplus in a special account (the
"Public Debt
Reduction Payment Account") to be used only for debt
reduction.
That account will be placed "off-budget" (as the Social
Security
surplus and Postal Service funds are currently treated).
The
statutory limit on the national debt will likewise be
reduced by that
amount.
The bill also places the Social Security surpluses and the
Medicare Hospital Insurance (HI) surpluses in a "lock-box"
(again
off-budget) to be used only for debt reduction, until Social
Security
and Medicare reform legislation is enacted. Any
legislation, other
than Social Security or Medicare reform measures, that would
dip
into these funds would be against the rules. A point of
order could
be raised which, if upheld, would require the House Rules
Committee, a majority of the House, and three-fifths of the
Senate
to agree to waive the rule. Even if an economic downturn or
national emergency occurs, it would be difficult to use any
of the
funds in these accounts for necessary spending.
Finally, no official statement, publication or material of
any Federal
government agency or instrumentality can include the Social
Security, Medicare, and “Public Debt Reduction Payment
Account”
surpluses as part of the overall budget surplus or deficit
totals.
Instead, the Social Security, Medicare, and "Public Debt
Reduction
Payment Account" balances must be submitted in separate
budget
documents. Presumably this means that the federal
government
could no longer speak or write about an overall (unified)
budget
surplus. This seems to be along the lines of "if we can’t
talk about
it, we can’t spend it."
From all reports, the bill faces a more difficult time in the Senate
since some Democrats intend to offer a series of amendments
that
will be opposed by Republican leadership.
"Protecting" the surplus from all spending seems to be the
primary
goal of this legislation, even through debt reduction makes
no
investment in the real needs of America’s people or
communities,
nor does it extend the solvency of Social Security or
Medicare.
Nevertheless, both parties seem to agree wholeheartedly on
the
primacy of debt reduction as policy.
