
Press Release: Government Secrecy Growing with Few Controls
by Guest Blogger, 9/7/2005
Washington -- Sep 4, 2005 -- Government secrecy is increasing in volume and scope, according to a report released today. The 2005 Secrecy Report Card, the second annual report from OpenTheGovernment.org, found secrecy in 2004 extended to more classified activity, more federal advisory meetings, more new patents deemed "secret," more domestic surveillance, and more new state laws restricting public access to information.
"The indicators we examined point to one conclusion: secrecy is growing," said Rick Blum, director of OpenTheGovernment.org. "As it expands secrecy -- spending billions, issuing orders, closing meetings, and operating out of the public eye -- government is shutting out the public. Secrecy robs us of the chance to make informed decisions, whether they are about protecting our communities or the direction of our country. This trend is fundamentally at odds with our democracy principles, and we must take steps to reverse it."
The report cites many indicators of growing secrecy, including:
- In 2004, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court approved 1,754 secret surveillance orders, rejecting none of the requests for such orders made by U.S. intelligence agencies. So while surveillance activity of foreign organizations and nationals under the jurisdiction of this secretive court has doubled in the past five years, the public knows nothing of whom or what is being investigated or how agencies are carrying out such investigations.
- "State secrecy" privilege that allows the White House to shield information from the public with little judicial review or opportunity for appeal has been invoked 23 times since 2001. By contrast, it was invoked only four times between 1953 and 1976 at the height of the Cold War.
- Nearly two-thirds (64 percent) of federal advisory committee meetings in 2004 were completely closed to the public, with still more partially closed. This undermines the purpose of the Federal Advisory Committee Act and the intent of Congress.
- The federal government has at least 50 overlapping and vague categories to keep "sensitive but unclassified" information from the public. Use of these categories allows government agencies or employees to manipulate access to public information (to hide embarrassing or inconvenient facts or to continue to profit from their distribution, for example) out of "security" concerns.
