Chronology of Events Related to the Istook Amendment

2/26/2002

From "Handcuffing America's Charities."The following chronology catalogues the major events related to
the Istook amendment. The chronology does not track the 1981 Heritage
Foundation proposal found in the Mandate for Leadership that is
similar to the Istook amendment. Nor does it trace meetings earlier
this year that involved the Heritage Foundation, Cato Institute,
Capital Research Center, and several congressional offices, including
House Majority Leader Richard Armey (R-TX) and his staff, Viriginia
Thomas.

It appears that the proponents of the Istook amendment, led by
Representatives Ernest Istook (R-OK), David McIntosh (R-IN) and
Robert Ehrlich (R-MD), will continue proposing versions of the
Istook amendment to attach to various bills.

June 29, 1995


  • Rep. David McIntosh (R-IN), chair of the House National Economic
    Growth, Natural Resources and Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee
    of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee, holds a hearing
    on political advocacy by federal grantees. Rep. Robert Ehrlich
    (R-MD) serves on the subcommittee. Several unofficial drafts of
    a proposed bill by Reps. Ernest Istook (R-OK), McIntosh, and Ehrlich
    have been obtained, but are not discussed at the hearing.

July 24, 1995


  • Senator Alan Simpson (R-WY) offers an amendment to the Lobby
    Reform Bill, which passes the Senate by a vote of 59-39. The amendment
    makes all 501(c)(4) nonprofit organizations (i.e., social welfare)
    that lobby ineligible to receive federal grants.

July 28, 1995


  • Rep. David McIntosh (R-IN), chair of the House National Economic
    Growth, Natural Resources and Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee
    of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee, holds a second
    hearing on political advocacy by federal grantees. Although a
    version of the Istook amendment is being debated in the House
    Appropriations Committee mark-up of the Labor-HHS-Education Appropriations
    bill, the hearing is not about the proposed bill.

August 2, 1995


  • Rep. David McIntosh (R-IN), chair of the House National Economic
    Growth, Natural Resources and Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee
    of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee, holds a third
    hearing on political advocacy by federal grantees. Still no witnesses
    have provided evidence of nonprofit grantees using federal funds
    to lobby. Although the hearing is not about the Istook amendment,
    the amendment has been attached to the Labor-HHS-Education Appropriations
    bill and the rule on the appropriations bill has just been completed.

August 4, 1995


  • House votes 232-189 against an amendment offered by Rep. David
    Skaggs (D-CO) to strike the Istook amendment from the Labor-HHS-Education
    appropriations bill. This amendment was authored by Representatives
    Ernest Istook (R-OK), David McIntosh (R-IN) and Robert Ehrlich
    (R-MD) and was widely opposed by charities across the country.

August 5, 1995


  • Senator Alan Simpson (R-WY) offers an amendment to the Treasury-Postal
    Service appropriations bill, which was approved by voice vote.
    The amendment makes 501(c)(4) nonprofit organizations with budgets
    of $10 million or more that lobby ineligible to receive federal
    grants.

September 28, 1995


  • Rep. David McIntosh (R-IN), chair of the House National Economic
    Growth, Natural Resources and Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee
    of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee, holds a fourth
    hearing on political advocacy by federal grantees - the first
    as an "investigative oversight" hearing. Subcommittee
    staff acknowledge they forged Alliance for Justice letterhead
    and falsified a document about federal grants received by the
    Alliance's membership.

October 18, 1995


  • Rep. David McIntosh (R-IN), chair of the House National Economic
    Growth, Natural Resources and Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee
    of the Government Reform and Oversight Committee, scheduled a
    fifth hearing on political advocacy by federal grantees for today,
    but then cancelled it. The only witness was the National Council
    of Senior Citizens. Another hearing planned for October 23 was
    also cancelled.

October 25, 1995


  • House-Senate conferees report the Treasury-Postal Service
    appropriations bill out with one amendment in disagreement - the
    Simpson language. Rep. Istook had tried to attach the Istook amendment
    from the Labor-HHS appropriations bill, but his attempt was rejected.
    He then proposed a second Istook amendment, which was also rejected.
    With the Simpson amendment reported out in disagreement, it meant
    that the House must vote separately on the amendment. Istook still
    hoped to offer his amendment as a substitute to the Simpson amendment,
    but the news media reports that the conferee's actions provided
    a devastating blow to the Istook amendment.

November 7, 1995


  • House Rules Committee votes to attach a new Istook amendment
    to the Continuing Resolution. The Treasury-Postal Service appropriations
    bill is temporarily shelved because of the controversy over the
    Istook amendment.

November 8, 1995


  • By a vote of 216-210, the full House approves the rule for
    the Continuing Resolution, which includes the new Istook amendment.
    The CR itself is passed later that evening by a vote of 230-197.
    Congress and the President must agree to a CR by midnight on November
    13 or large parts of government must shut down.

November 9, 1995


  • Senate votes 49-47 to replace the Istook language on the Continuing
    Resolution with new language offered by Senators Alan Simpson
    (R-WY) and Larry Craig (R-ID). (On a first vote the Simpson-Craig
    amendment lost, but Majority Leader Robert Dole (R-KS) brought
    it up a second time and won.) The Simpson-Craig amendment requires
    new reporting requirements and prohibits 501(c)(4) nonprofit organizations
    with revenues of $3 million or more from getting grants. House
    proponents of the Istook amendment are on Senate floor lobbying
    for the Simpson-Craig amendment and hail the vote as a major victory
    to stop "welfare for lobbyists."

November 10, 1995


  • Istook is on early morning TV praising the Simpson-Craig amendment.
    But later in the morning says he opposes the amendment. He prepares
    to offer the Istook amendment again. Some Republicans voice their
    objection to Istook and members take to chanting and wearing signs
    that say "Free Ernie" (as in Ernie Istook). Appropriations
    Chair Bob Livingston (R-LA) states that there are technical problems
    with the Simpson-Craig amendment and makes a motion to strike
    the language from the Continuing Resolution. Istook does not offer
    his amendment.
  • By striking the Simpson-Craig amendment the CR has to go back
    to the Senate for approval. By the time the House acts, the Senate
    has left for the Veterans Day weekend and will not return until
    late on Monday, November 13, the day the government may need to
    shut down.

November 13, 1995


  • Senate concurs with the House Continuing Resolution, which
    eliminates the Simpson-Craig amendment. The President receives
    the bill late in the day and follows through on his veto threat,
    shutting down parts of the government.

November 15, 1995


  • House takes up the Treasury-Postal Service appropriations
    conference report and votes to drop the Simpson language, which
    had been reported in disagreement. Istook decides not to offer
    his amendment, stating that he will put it on other bills. The
    appropriations conference report goes to the Senate for approval.

November 28, 1995


  • Reps. Istook and McIntosh withdraw amendments to theLobby
    Disclosure Bill after early votes clearly indicate that the House
    will reject all amendments. Appoval of any amendments, including
    the proposed Istook and McIntosh amendments, would send the bill
    back to the Senate, where its future would be in question.

November 29, 1995


  • The House unanimously passes (421-0) the Lobby Reform Bill
    with no amendments, and send it to the the President for his signature.
    The original Simpson amendment to prevent 501(c)(4) nonprofits
    that lobby from getting federal funds is part of the bill that
    passes.

December 19, 1995


  • President signs the Lobby Disclosure Act of 1995 into law.

Note: While the chronology only lists three Istook amendments,
there were many more drafts. In fact, there have been so many
versions of the amendment that it has confused reporters and charities
throughout the country.